Dr Tattersall’s Dilemma

The wrong children, or the wrong question?

Walk the Meanwood Valley Trail in Leeds and you may want to explore the tantalising little paths between rhododendron thickets in the public gardens of ‘The Hollies’, a Victorian mansion. Venture a little further up the hill and on to Weetwood Lane and the gatepost reveals a bronze plaque testifying to the heroic life and death of Major Harold Brown DSO MC, killed in action, aged 39, on 23rd March 1914. This tragedy led to Major Brown’s father donating The Hollies to Leeds City Council. The other gatepost has a matching plaque recording this gift on June 1st 1921. For most of the next 35 years the house was employed to help local children at risk in a much longer war, as yet unresolved, between humanity and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The Hollies became a ‘sanatorium school’ also known as a ‘preventorium’.

Robert Koch had isolated the slow-growing tuberculosis bacillus in 1882, X-rays were discovered shortly afterwards and, in 1908, a skin test that measured reaction to tuberculosis protein. Effective drugs against tuberculosis (TB) were not available until the early 1950s so the mainstay of treatment for the first half of the last century was the sanatorium, where patients were given good food and exposed to sunlight and lots of fresh air.

Public health physicians, like Dr Norman Tattersall, TB Officer for Leeds, were faced with the challenge of what to do about children who had been in close contact with a person with ‘open TB’, often a parent or grandparent. Skin tests revealed which of these children reacted to tuberculin. An X-ray examination might have shown signs of early infection, but most of these children would recover on their own without treatment. However, many were living in overcrowded slum accommodation, with little exposure to sunlight, fresh air or a good diet. A popular option in the period between the two world wars was to place such children in the more healthy surroundings of a preventorium. The first of these institutions was opened in New Jersey in 1909; they soon became widespread in North America and Northern Europe.

The Leeds Preventorium: ‘Weetwood The Hollies Sanatorium School’ was granted certificate number 29788 by the National Board of Education on April 1st 1925.(1) It was recorded as a boarding school with 40 beds and a classroom for 30 children. The usual length of stay was six months, but this was extended if the children needed it, or their home circumstances were of particular concern. Dr Muriel Bywaters, Chief Inspector of Tuberculosis Schools for the Ministry of Education is recorded as visiting The Hollies five times between 1929 and 1945. Her earlier reports are not available, but her report from June 21st 1934 is in the National Archives.(1) It runs to only three pages and it is clear that she is generally satisfied with the care and education provided. She commends Dr Tattersall, for his regular weekly visits. She advises on the quality of the children’s diet, which does not lack in quantity. A typical day’s menu was recorded as:

8am Breakfast    Porridge, bacon, bread and butter, tea.

12 noon Dinner   Roast beef, 2 vegetables, suet puddings.       

4pm Tea               Bread and butter, scones, tea.         

6.30pm Supper   Bread and butter or dripping, milk.

Dr Bywaters advised that the diet should be supplemented with fresh fruit and salad. On this visit there were 40 resident children aged 3-13 years.

She noted that: ‘the children appeared interested and were doing good careful neat work and satisfactory results are obtained. I heard singing and saw dancing, both of which were particularly well done. My inspection included also writing composition, arithmetic and handwork. The work is careful, neat and well finished. I saw good specimens of pewter work, leather work, fancy stitchery, raffia work, cane work and stool seating.’(1)

Four years later, on September 15th 1938, Dr Bywaters noted that of the 39 children, with an age range of 2-12 years, 22 were aged between 2 and 6, most of this latter group were between 3 and 5. She remained happy with the standards of education and care at The Hollies but recommended a change in furniture, materials and teaching methods so that the needs of the nursery age children could be properly met.

Although not present on the day of that visit, Dr Tattersall is recorded as continuing to attend the preventorium every week. He was, by then, a national expert on the subject, having published an article on ‘The Tuberculosis Preventorium’, as sole author, in the British Journal of Tuberculosis in 1932.(2) This review was based on his experience in Leeds, and as part of a British delegation to the USA and Canada in 1930 when he was given the task of assessing and reporting back on the subject of preventoria.

Dr Tattersall was very impressed with the high standards, particularly in Toronto, where the preventorium had 120 beds, including 32 for babies up to four years. He noted that: ‘the building is admirably adapted to its purpose, large verandahs or ‘sleeping porches’ opening from the wards which allow of rest and sleep under open-air conditions all the year round.’ An indoor playground measuring 66 feet by 40 feet contained swings, see-saws, a chute, merry-go-round, sandpit and ample space for floor games.

Although a conscientious physician to the children at The Hollies, it is clear from his article that Dr Tattersall had his doubts. His main concern was whether the right children were being admitted. He noted that it was widely accepted that: ‘Under ordinary working class domestic conditions we can assume it is practically impossible for children living with an infected adult to escape infection’.

It is important to understand that infection with TB is not the same as disease. 70% of healthy British 15 year olds in the 1930s had evidence from skin testing that they had, at one stage, been infected with TB. The majority of children had acquired some TB infection, but their immune systems had dealt with it without giving rise to noticeable symptoms. A minority had infections which progressed to clinical disease, which, at the time, killed thousands of British people every year, many of them as young adults.

Dr Tattersall eloquently expresses his dilemma:
‘may we go further and suggest that of such infected children those who develop symptoms or present stigmata of infection are the ones whose immunising response is being fully called into action with the consequent development of a fairly effective degree of immunity, whilst the infected but symptomless child is harbouring tubercle bacilli by virtue of his natural resistance and without the development of active immunity?’(2)

Although he was a strong supporter of the benefits of good food, fresh air and sunlight, he questions whether the right group of children had been selected for the special care and environment available at places like The Hollies.

It is not unusual for a clinical dilemma to be overtaken by events, particularly during the 20th century when so many spectacular advances in medical science were made. Dr Tattersall’s question about who should be admitted to a preventorium became largely academic when the era of sanatoria came to an end. Specific and effective anti-tuberculous antibiotics became available during the 1950s. The Hollies was put to other uses, as an old people’s home and, more recently, as a hostel for single homeless women.

‘Primum non nocere’ – ‘first, do no harm’ is a founding principle of medicine.
We can safely assume that when physicians of the inter-war years, like Dr Tattersall, had children removed from their overcrowded and often insanitary dwellings to be placed in the airy, nutritious and more wholesome environment of The Hollies, that it was self-evident to them that the selected children would benefit from this intervention. The available archives contain no comments or reports on the emotional impact of removing sometimes very young children from their homes and parents.

Observations about the children’s welfare in other preventoria are very positive. A local physician in Toronto, Dr Parsons, is quoted as saying that the children there have ‘a whale of a time’.(2) Dr Bywaters reports from her 1938 visit(1) about the educational needs of the much younger group of children she met at The Hollies. She recommends smaller tables and chairs but there is no mention of the emotional needs of the children, no record of when, or if, parents or other family members were allowed to visit. Access to the logbook for The Hollies, held by West Yorkshire Archives, is restricted, and not available at the time of writing.

The first controlled trial of streptomycin, which heralded the revolution in TB treatment, was published in 1948, the same year that James Robertson, a psychiatric social worker, started work with Dr John Bowlby at the Tavistock Clinic in London. His work was to prove, arguably, just as revolutionary.

Robertson was employed to make observations on separated young children. He was sent to the children’s ward at the Central Middlesex Hospital in London. Over the next few years, he was shocked to see the impact of the separation of young children from their parents, as a result of hospital admission. Parental visiting to hospitals was strongly discouraged and it was not unusual for very young children to have no contact with their parents for weeks or months.

Paterson described a devastating and predictable sequence of behaviour shown by these very young children: – protest, despair and then detachment. He found it very difficult to persuade the medical and nursing establishment of the importance of his observations. This changed when he produced the film: ‘A two year-old goes to hospital’ (3) in 1952. A review in The Nursing Times is eloquent: ‘The restraint and objectivity of the film may at first reassure, for the child is unusually composed for her age, but few nurses will doubt the degree of her distress, the signs of which they have so often felt powerless to relieve.’

The staffing at the Hollies was recorded in 1934 as:

Matron Miss Read
1 Trained Sister 3 Assist. Nurses (one on night duty)
4 Domestics + Charwoman 3 times a week
2 Teachers – Mrs Hodgkinson C.T. – Headteacher
Miss Robinson H.F. – Assistant Teacher

From this it is reasonable to assume that only one trained nurse (either Matron or Sister) plus an assistant nurse, would be on night duty. The only change in staff noted in the 1938 report is a replacement for the headteacher, who had become ill, so the nurse/care staffing probably remained the same.

We can hope that all the staff were caring, motherly individuals who recognised the emotional needs of the children and, either by instinct or experience, knew that it was important for each child to have a key worker with whom they could develop some sort of positive attachment. However, it seems much more likely that serious harm was done to these young children through lack of knowledge about their emotional needs.

The separation of young children from their families was done with the best of intentions but probably did not save many lives and may have caused lasting emotional damage, particularly to the younger children. We cannot blame the professionals of the day for their lack of knowledge. It is good that people like Dr Tattersall were questioning what they were doing, although, with hindsight, he was not asking a question of much more importance to the children.

References:
1. Educational Records for Weetwood The Hollies Sanatorium School.
National Archives ED 32/1027
2. Tattersall N, 1932. The Tuberculosis Preventorium.
British Journal of Tuberculosis 26 3 121-127
3. A two year old goes to hospital (Robertson Films) 1952

Postscript:
TB was declared a global emergency by the World Health Organisation in 1993. Death rates from TB worldwide have declined 45% since 2000 but 9 million people died of TB in 2013. There is still no reliable and simple test for TB disease in children. Approximately half a million of the world’s children become ill with TB every year, and many die.

© David Cundall 2014

One thought on “Dr Tattersall’s Dilemma”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *