Sunday 24th June 2005 was a rest day on our walk from Leeds to Iona. We took umbrellas and swimming costumes, to cover all eventualities, and headed over Waterside Hill from St.John’s Town of Dalry. Pam sat and painted the burn while I was more bitten by midges than any creative impulse. Wandering up the road, I noticed that a rash of dry cowpats had lifted the superficial layer of tarmac creating ulcers which matched the shape of each cowpat exactly. This phenomenon demanded an explanation, and has niggled me ever since. Was it the tensile strength of the drying cowpat or the weakness of the tarmac that caused the erosion of the road? Does my observation have wider implications?
Cow dung is mainly plant material that even the stomach of a cow has not managed to digest. The rumen, reticulum, omasum and obamasum are not, as many believe, ‘four stomachs’ but four parts of one cow stomach. Whichever way one might wish to describe these cavities, it is what gets through them and the guts beyond that eventually forms the dung. This excreta will include cells from the gut lining, various enzymes secreted by the cow and myriads of bacteria. Cowpats come in many shapes and sizes – some resemble deep pan pizzas, in shape at least, others are thinner and flatter. The cowpats on the Galloway road had started as a wet variety – they were flat and the splat as they hit the ground was still evident in their tentacular outline. Cow dung has many uses as manure, fuel, a source of biogas and (when burnt by the Maasai) an insect repellent. Further towards Iona, while visiting the nature reserve at the head of Loch Gruinart on Islay, we learnt about the role of cowpats in the ecology of choughs. However, cowpats have not, to my knowledge, been previously recorded as an agent of road erosion, so it is their adhesive and tensile properties that I wish to examine further.
There is much written about the stickiness of cow dung and how this property makes the substance so useful as a component of traditional plaster in many cultures, but I can find no reference as to why it is so adherent. It is reasonable to presume that the cow’s colon secretes a lot of mucus that contributes to the stickiness of its end-product. Also, the digestion of plant material by microbes will produce mucilaginous compounds which add to the adherence of the dung.
The tensile strength of a particular cowpat will depend mainly on its solid constituents. If the cow has been unfortunate enough to be reared indoors and fed on grain, its dung will fall apart. The fine examples of grass-fed Galloway dung, which I saw on that midsummer’s day, were a mass of interlocking cellulose fibres. The fact that it was June provides a further clue about the strength of these particular cowpats. When they first landed, they would have flowed into whatever irregularities there were in the surface of the road. On a hot day, with an almost inevitable Scottish breeze blowing, the cowpats must have dried very quickly. The cellulose fibres would have shrunk as a mesh, in the same way as the fibrin in the scab on a wound contracts. As the contraction continued, something had to give way. On this occasion, on this road, with some of the cowpat fibres stuck like climbers’ fingers in minute cracks in the road, it was the superficial layer of the tarmac that gave way under the strain.
I saw no other evidence that this road was particularly badly made. The surface was not smooth, but no different in that respect to other country lanes. There was the usual erosion at the edges where tree roots, temporary watercourses or wayward tractors had had their way. There was none of the wanton decay of the surface which I have seen on some African roads where a corrupt contractor has cut corners with his materials and engineering.
A Scottish country road is designed for floodwaters, snow and ice but not for rare hot summers. A review of Met Office data for Galloway in May and June 2005 does not record extreme weather conditions, although there was a period of high pressure in mid-May when temperatures at night were close to freezing and daytime temperatures reached the low twenties (Celsius) in some places. Perhaps the clue is in the contrasting temperatures – not so much between night and day but between the tarmac at the edge of the cowpat and that in its shade. Let us imagine the midday sun beating down on this road on a hot day shortly before my visit. The sun, abetted by a warm breeze, rapidly dries out a fresh wet cowpat which is already well stuck to the road. The tarmac at the edges of the cowpat is close to liquefying temperature, the tarmac within the confines of the cowpat’s outline is cooler as it is protected from the sun and there is still some evaporation from the cowpat’s surface to cool it further. The cellulose fibres contract as they dry out. The tarmac gives way – all the way round the edge of the cowpat.
I am not a physicist, but I believe I have found a reasonable explanation for the destructive power of the Galloway cowpat. This draws on the nature of the cowpat, the road, the weather and the interaction between these components of the system. The first two questions posed by my observation have been answered to my satisfaction, but are there any wider implications?
The relationship between Homo sapiens and Bos primigenius taurus is usually thought to be one of mutual benefit. The statistics speak for themselves. There are now 1.3 billion cattle worldwide, descended from only about eighty cattle in Turkey 10,500 years ago. Paleoanthropologist Pat Shipton, from Penn State University, has recently highlighted the role in human evolution of our mutual relationships with species we have domesticated. She calls this the ‘animal connection’ in human evolution and cites a number of examples, notably the domestication of the wolf. She argues that humankind are unique in their taming of other animals, although this is not the case when one considers the farming of aphids by some species of ant. Putting aside that minor quibble, her general thesis about the mutuality of our relationships with some other species stands up to scrutiny well.
We might assume that the domestication of cattle has been solely for our benefit. Our ability to enclose, pacify and breed these animals and protect them from predators gives us a ready source of milk, meat, leather, bones and horns. However, Shipton observes that our own evolution has itself been directly affected by our close relationship with cattle. For example, adult populations that consume a lot of cow milk are much more likely to have the gene to produce lactase, the enzyme that digests lactose, a sugar found in cow milk. Some human groups, like the Maasai, have evolved cultures whose destiny is intricately linked with their herds of cattle.
In general, cattle have done very well out of their domestication. Not only has their world population passed one billion, but their quality of life has, generally, never been better. Veterinarians have ensured that cattle are protected from, or treated for, diseases that used to decimate them. Scientists and fieldworkers freed the world of rinderpest, a disease of cattle, in 2011, well before we managed to achieve this goal for polio, measles or malaria in humans. There are, admittedly, some unfortunate beasts who are force-fed in factory sheds, but most are looked after very well. Perhaps we are not so far from Douglas Adams’ description of the cow that wants to be eaten; cattle as a species have done so well because many of the human race like to eat them or consume their products. It can be argued that it is in the interests of cattle to produce meat and milk that we like to consume. Is it better for cattle to be humanely killed in an abattoir than to die of old age or illness?
We must, however, consider the possibility that the apparent mutually beneficial evolution between cattle and humans is hiding a long-term plan by cattle to dominate the world, with human beings as their unsuspecting accomplices. This idea is not as bizarre as it first appears. Human beings are well-known to be a very destructive species and are responsible for a current mass extinction which is frightening to contemplate. Species that humans see as a threat are usually mercilessly pursued, although belated attempts are now being made to save some of the most beautiful, like the Asian tiger. A species that wants to prosper in an increasingly man-made world would be well-advised to cooperate with such an efficient aggressor and, if possible, come to be seen as an essential part of human existence.
Let us consider some of the major threats to human welfare in the 21st century. We are told that our children may not live for as long as we will. Obesity and heart disease are, at least partly, related to diets rich in dairy products. The consumption of red meat (predominately beef) is linked to bowel cancer. The decline in breastfeeding in many urbanising societies has serious consequences for child and adult health and only occurs because cow milk products are readily available.
There is, admittedly, no obvious connection between cattle and the nuclear threat, although a cursory glance at the fields around Sellafield indicates that our activities are being closely monitored. However the biggest danger is probably climate change. Vast swathes of forest have been cut down to create grazing land. This has a doubly detrimental effect on human existence – we lose the trees that help to ensure an equable climate and the atmosphere gains a lot more methane, a potent greenhouse gas, from the digestive tracts of cattle.
Why have human beings not realised that cattle are now controlling us, rather than vice versa? One of the main reasons must be that cows do not look or act as if they are intelligent. It requires an impressive self-discipline for all of them to maintain their stolid exterior while gradually achieving their goal. Those big eyes and ears, which look so innocent, are processing huge amounts of information about us and passing it on, not via some pyramidal hierarchy – that would be too risky – but shared in a collective consciousness within and between herds.
It is reasonable to assume that their strategy has been to imperceptibly usurp the dominance of humans. The perennial patience of cattle has coped with major insults like the routine castration of many males, mass slaughter and incineration associated with foot and mouth disease and the gross insult of feeding animal products to them, leading to bovine spongiform encephalopathy.
Every interaction between cattle and people should be re-examined with the lens of impending bovine superiority. Consider the cowpats on the road by the Garrochburn. A cow with benign intentions would ensure that its faeces landed on pasture to improve the nutrition of its grass. Only a cow engaged in the war of attrition on humans would deposit its dung on a road. In fact, it had probably taken an extra drink from the burn to ensure that the erosive consistency of the cowpats was just right, bearing in mind its diet and the weather conditions.
When you next gaze into the inscrutable eyes of a Friesian or Guernsey, consider what is really happening in the balance of interests between cattle and humankind. Their cunning ancestors, the aurochs, were not called ‘Bos primigenius’ for nothing.
© David Cundall